Preserving Architectural heritage with 3Dsurvey – Castle of Sobota
Architectural Heritage is of increasing significance to society. Evidence of past societies can provide a sense of belonging and security to modern societies and be an anchor in a rapidly changing world. In many societies, too, heritage can be an important definer of identity. Understanding the past can also be of great help for managing the problems of the present and the future”
The “UNESCO 1972 World Heritage Convention” indicates cultural heritage as monuments, groups of buildings, and sites etc., and the Castle of Sobota is one of those buildings. Due to cost conditions, standard improvements, lack of original materials or safety, sometimes parts of the building simply need to be replaced, so is not always possible to preserve Architectural heritage in its original setup, but it can be done quite similarly. With the help of surveying!
In this article, we focus on roof construction substitution, where the client wanted to understand how they can make use of 3Dsurvey in order to measure a 3D area of the roof of Sobota Castle. The castle’s roof will be renovated, and the stakeholders needed to know what the roof area is, so that they can plan appropriate quantity of roof tiles. The other specific task was of course, to preserve the design, look and feel and architecture as the roof get renovated. The problem might seem elementary; however, it is not exactly so. A castle is an old object, and its roof has an irregular shape as you can see below:
To get the best possible 3D model of the castle, our client mapped it in double grid mode with camera pitch of 60 degrees downward at a flight altitude of 50m. They placed 5 ground control points around castle area as they wanted to achieve the best possible accuracy (in this case RTK telemetry alone would offer sufficient model accuracy):
As in most cases, standard processing workflow in 3Dsurvey was used. The workflow offered is designed by the surveyors, so in 97% of the cases, users do not need to change the steps as they can just follow an intuitive workflow by design.
- Bundle adjustment on aerial images
- Point cloud calculation of complete castle (this one is especially nice):
On the pointcloud, they classified ground points first:
So that out of the ground points, they were able to make a Digital terrain model of the castle area:
Then they went into the CAD section of 3Dsurvey. To simplify CAD drawing they manipulated Bounding box so, that only the castle roof was shown:
They prepared 3 layers in CAD: Roof outside area, Roof Breaklines and Roof Atrium Boundary:
On Roof Outside Area boundary, they drew outside boundary of roof area:
On Atrium layer, they drew the inside border of roof Area:
Then finally on Roof breaklines layer they drew all the breaklines for the roof:
The final CAD drawing had looked like this:
They then used Triangulate CAD data to make a mesh 3D model of the roof:
Now everything was prepared to calculate the roof area. To calculate the 3D area of the roof, they made use of Calculate volume function, because calculate volume function returns 3D area as well. One of future versions of 3Dsurvey will include standalone calculate 3D area of mesh function, but until then, using calculate volume function will offer a good alternate workflow.
When calculating volume, they used Digital terrain model as Initial surface Triangulated Mesh from CAD data surface as Final surface. In the volume calculation window, they chose From CAD option, and selected layers Roof Outside Area and Atrium:
Result of this operation were two volumes – volume and 3D area for roof outside area and volume and 3D area for Atrium area:
This was now the whole roof Outside Area 3D area:
And this is how the Atrium 3D area and volume looked like:
The Total Roof 3D area was the difference between the two 3D areas so Roof Outside 3D Area 3D area (3473.19 m^2) minus Atrium 3D Area (479.85 m^2) :
3D Castle roof area = 3473.19 m^2 – 479.85 m^2 = 2,993.34 m^2
Using the traditional roof measurement techniques, it would be close to impossible to measure accurate area of this kind of complicated roof, but with help of 3Dsurvey and drone photogrammetry the task was relatively easy and significantly user friendlier than traditional approaches.
Again, we quickly recap the steps needed to calculate the 3D area:
- Record aerial images of object of interests
- Import the images in 3Dsurvey, run Bundle Adjustment and calculate dense point cloud
- Classify the pointcloud and produce Digital terrain model
- In CAD draw the outer boundary of object of interest and put it on layer Outer boundary
- In CAD draw the inner boundaries of object of interest (in our case Atrium Boundary)
- Draw object Breaklines
- Calculate the Triangulated mesh surface out of outer and inner boundaries and Breaklines
- Calculate the volumes with DTM as initial surface and triangulated mesh as final surface. For area definition use inner and outer boundary CAD layers.
- The final volume is the difference between 3D Area of Outer boundary minus 3D Area of inner Boundaries
This can easily be performed in less than a day. Total terrain work will take less than one hour, with drone flight taking about 15 minutes, and the rest of the time will be spent on unpacking, setting up, packing the equipment. Then the processing in 3Dsurvey, after pointcloud is completed will again take about one hour. We will need to draw CAD boundaries and then calculate the volumes. In short, this kind of project will take about half of the day, when we count in travel to and from the site as well.